Scarborough Fair Restaurant

Good visit. Appetizer was a crab cake. Dinner was fish and fish. All very good. The menu has changed a lot from 30 years ago. It was still decorated for Valentine's Day which made it special and unplanned.

What a darling place for a date night dinner or just a fabulous family dinner. We loved the decoration for Valentine’s Day. There was entertainment at the piano bar which was nice. We highly recommend the spanakopita, cowboy steak and mushroom raviolis. Service and food were excellent!

Food was cold, waitress was too busy to even listen to us. Never explained the specials and was annoyed that I asked her what was actually in it or what it came with. I ordered Chicken Milanaise, expecting a thin pounded, moist cutlet. It was a dry hunk of fried chicken- inedible. I asked for a side of sauce to help. Room temp sauce, 20 minutes later for my ice cold meal. The salads/dressings for the table were all wrong. No water refills, no dirty dish picked up between courses. Bread basket was cold. Not even 1 pat of butter per roll. She didn't know the soups or the vegetables of the day. I found a special holiday cocktail online, when I asked for it, she said they didn't have it. I pulled it up on my phone to show her. It was the only good thing i had. Even the ricotta cheesecake was dry. Our very tight table was in front of a window. The glare was so bright you actually couldn't see. I asked the mgr. If there was a shade or a way to close the curtain. No there was nothing they could do. UNACCEPTABLE! There is no way the sun doesn't come through everyday? And nowhere to move a party of 8 already in a space designed for 6. It Is a gorgeous place but I wouldn't pay for an overpriced terrible meal again. There are alot of better luxurious boutique restaurants now, that would treat us WAY better!

Absolutely stunning environment. The atmosphere of this restaurant is a 1000/10. I would definitely come back! Try and secure one of the private tables by the stairs if you have a special occasion. The fall harvest sangria was amazing! The perfect romantic date night location.

Great atmosphere along with generous drinks and delicious food. The short rib was awesome and the chicken was perfect. We were sitting in a great spot that was semi private, quiet and yet able to see most of the restaurant and enjoy the ambiance. A repeat for sure.